UK CUP [Match Reporting/Disputes]

13

Comments

  • NOJawad wrote: »
    EVEN THOUGH IF WE LOSS- I DO NOT REALLY CARE ! , ALL I CARE ABOUT IS RIPPING YOU GUYS , AND YOU"RE LIKE : OMGGGGG HOW CAN WE WIN and you are just bad :) ! GL HIPPO 10-5 ! then braave is nthing comparing to justpro "qualityyy-" now , HE WAS ALSO RIPPIN' YOU :) if his PC hasn't crashed , we'll win you guys like 10-2 or sth.. :) GJ ! HIPPO TO THE FINALS

    The first room you made, brave entered and stated that the password was easy, when I re-made the room, he also managed to get into the room meaning you gave him the password.
    When you had all 5 members [not brave] in the room, he entered, so we guessed you were planning to do something dodgy anyway.

    Some of our players had bad FPS and ping issues, but we didn't get any random guy to play for us. Also, I highly doubt that the player who was supposedly meant to play, played all day only for his PC to randomly crash a few minutes before the match was meant to start.

    We were not aware if brave was a sub or not and only checked when the match had finished, once we found out he wasn't, we obviously disputed.

    Once again, you obviously knew he was not meant to play and didn't inform us. Maybe if you had read the rules, this problem would not have occurred.
  • Mmm greaaat kfc ! As i"v just said , we do not care about the win though , all we care is ripping them n they are just trying to find any explanation to win the game ? Seriously not i"m not even sad , happy now seeing the guys doin' this !
    Whats your ign ? ;)
  • Mr_Zhang wrote: »
    The first room you made, brave entered and stated that the password was easy, when I re-made the room, he also managed to get into the room meaning you gave him the password.
    When you had all 5 members [not brave] in the room, he entered, so we guessed you were planning to do something dodgy anyway.

    Some of our players had bad FPS and ping issues, but we didn't get any random guy to play for us. Also, I highly doubt that the player who was supposedly meant to play, played all day only for his PC to randomly crash a few minutes before the match was meant to start.

    We were not aware if brave was a sub or not and only checked when the match had finished, once we found out he wasn't, we obviously disputed.

    Once again, you obviously knew he was not meant to play and didn't inform us. Maybe if you had read the rules, this problem would not have occurred.



    well , you still buddy talking about the results , May i just explain you something , braave asked tyze in our first match if he can play with us as a normal member , He agreed saying " if GYX's members agree , you're in ! " . That's why we called him after justpro's pc crushing. WE OFC WONT PLAY 4v5 ! anyways cya guys , GL - HIPPO TO THE FINALS !
  • Trying to find any explanation to win the game?
    You knew playing braave was not allowed and you chose to do so. You risked the consequences and thought it would work, it didn't. I'm not surprised if swapping your 5th and braave was planned all along. Hard luck.
  • INA OTHER WAY >> braave WAS RIPPPING YOU , THATS WHY YOU DID THIS , IF YOU GUYS GOT ANY PROBLEMS PLAYING VS BRAAVE , YOU WOULD HAVE SAID BEFORE WE START :) YOU CAN JUST SAY ! EASLIY !!
    you did this well
  • Wivz_CF wrote: »
    Trying to find any explanation to win the game?
    You knew playing braave was not allowed and you chose to do so. You risked the consequences and thought it would work, it didn't. Hard luck.

    AS I SAID , braave asked tyze in our first match if he can play with us as a normal member , He agreed saying " if GYX's members agree , you're in ! " . That's why we called him after justpro's pc crushing. > THIS MEANS THAT HES A SUB FOR US , just READ CAREFULLY
  • NOJawad wrote: »
    INA OTHER WAY >> braave WAS RIPPPING YOU , THATS WHY YOU DID THIS , IF YOU GUYS GOT ANY PROBLEMS PLAYING VS BRAAVE , YOU WOULD HAVE SAID BEFORE WE START :) YOU CAN JUST SAY ! EASLIY !!
    you did this well

    We only checked after the match that braave wasn't in the roster. We did have a problem playing against a player who wasn't in the roster, most teams would .
  • Please explain how brave kept entering our room when you had 5 in the room already.
    Sounds kinda strange how justpro's PC was fine all day but crashed a few minutes before the match starts.

    Once again, the anticheat caused some issues with some of our members but we carried on playing, that is the risk of not having any subs on your team.

    Edit: Brave was not added to your subs on the roster as far as I can see and is still not on it.
  • Great , Seems that you guys won get it , And i ofc wont waste my time talking to yaa :) cya !
    GOODLUCK TO THE FINALS
  • Still waiting for the explanation, why did you give brave the password before justpro's PC crashed, when you had 5 in the room.

    Clearly it's you who doesn't understand. Read the rules.

    And what is it your trying to get across? That you won us?

    Congrats on that. :D
  • NOJawad wrote: »
    AS I SAID , braave asked tyze in our first match if he can play with us as a normal member , He agreed saying " if GYX's members agree , you're in ! " . That's why we called him after justpro's pc crushing. > THIS MEANS THAT HES A SUB FOR US , just READ CAREFULLY

    Even if tyze did allow Brave to participate in this match, as quoted in the rules "Rosters may not be changed within 24 hours of a match." If you wanted to Brave to attend this competition, you should have put him down as a sub from the beginning. Instead of causing all this additional situations.
    NOJawad wrote: »
    Great , Seems that you guys won get it , And i ofc wont waste my time talking to yaa :) cya !
    GOODLUCK TO THE FINALS

    I'm glad your brain is able to comprehend all this at once. You just "wasted" about 3 hours worth of talking to us. Good job to that Egyptian logic.
  • Wivz_CF wrote: »
    We only checked after the match that braave wasn't in the roster. We did have a problem playing against a player who wasn't in the roster, most teams would .

    What are the decisions against Novum Vetus vs. PhiLipPiNes, are we going to re schedule or ..?
  • MsMaxiNe wrote: »
    What are the decisions between Novum Vetus vs. PhiLipPiNes, are we going to re schedule or ..?

    Add me on xfire: wivzcf
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    k tyze i've been told by brave that he asked u whether he can play or not and u said ya and i had no time to add him as i've not been on for 2 weeks or so
    so why the fck would they say that brave " isn't in the roster " just after they got their asses whooped and lost 5 to 10 they should've told us b4 playing not after getting lost
    and since we broke the rules but we won and they accepted to play vs braave we deserve at least a RM ,
    u can't just qualify 'em like they didn't lose ....

    Let me quote what you just said "k tyze i've been told by brave that he asked u whether he can play or not and u said ya." So you didn't clarify this? You just assumed Brave can just play without notifying the roster changes or letting the opposition know.
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    1stly Wivz was the 1 who made the room and he didn't give the pw to any of us
    2ndly we deserve to get qualified if it's a " CF " tournament as it's supposed to be
    since u guys lost u can't just get qualified as we " broke " the rulez that's what i'm trying to say

    We made three different rooms, with three different passwords and he managed to get into all three saying "easy pw." Later, he plays for your team. I did not tell you the password, your team invited him into all three rooms .
    You broke the rules, I think you find it does result into your team being disqualified and Hippo going through. You knew you were breaking the rules yet decided to go through with using braave as a player when he was not in your roster.
    "2ndly we deserve to get qualified if it's a " CF " tournament as it's supposed to be"
    What does that even mean?
  • It's quite blatant that you invited brave into the room, I just would like to know why?
    Were you planning on using him from the beginning?

    Obviously you have to add any subs and edit your roster via the forums. That's just common sense. I don/t see what point your trying to argue. That it's fine to win a match by breaking the rules?

    Edit: Please don't say you did not invite him/give him the password because none of us knew him before the match. Or perhaps it was magic that he was able to enter all rooms without any invites. :L
  • GYX broke the rules bringing braave into the game as he was not in the teams roster. Teams get disqualified for breaking the rules, GYX broke a rule and got disqualified, I really don't see what the arguments are about, It's just as simple as that.

    @NOJawad: My IGN is KFC
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    1stly Wivz was the 1 who made the room and he didn't give the pw to any of us
    2ndly we deserve to get qualified if it's a " CF " tournament as it's supposed to be
    since u guys lost u can't just get qualified as we " broke " the rulez that's what i'm trying to say

    This still does answer what Mr_Zhang has just asked "Still waiting for the explanation, why did you give brave the password before justpro's PC crashed, when you had 5 in the room."

    This really does not go in the favor of team GYX, as from the point of view of team Hippo it seems like team GYX had their main line up but coincidentally after re-making the room one of GYX's line up crashes moments before the match begins.

    If this is the cause why not notify team Hippo that he has crashed and then they can decide whether to postpone the match. Instead of letting a player which isn't listed in the roster play.

    Also, you did not clarify Brave to be a sub you just assumed Brave said he could and you let him participate.
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    it simply means that we're a better team than u
    and we simply won :)
    but u can't just accept that
    u'll lose the next match anyway as u're not supposed to be there

    Clearly losing one match means that your a better team than us. It's not hard to win a match by breaking the rules.

    Even if we do lose the next match, I don't see how it concerns you.

    Just out of curiosity, why did you give bravee the password when you already had 5 in the room. :O
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    well about mrzhang question
    braave wanted to nade and i refused since it's " against the rulez " so one of my teammates might have invited him as we considered him a "SUB" pretty simple eh ?

    There's clearly no point posting here anymore, seeing as previously you said that we gave him the password and now one of your members invited him to "nade spec". If your going to lie, try to make it a good one.

    Since when did we ever accuse you of cheating in a scrim and breaking the rules is called a fair match? Maybe in Cuckooland but not here.
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    it simply means that we're a better team than u
    and we simply won :)
    but u can't just accept that
    u'll lose the next match anyway as u're not supposed to be there

    It does not simply mean that your team is better than Hippo's. I'm sure Hippo would of gladly admit defeat if Brave was on the roster. But since he wasn't how can you be so certain that Hippo wouldn't be able to accept the fact they lost. It's evident that you can't accept losing since you broke the rules, that is why you are still here trying to prove nothing.
    Chrisve1 wrote: »
    well about mrzhang question
    braave wanted to nade and i refused since it's " against the rulez " so one of my teammates might have invited him as we considered him a "SUB" pretty simple eh ?

    "Considered" So he isn't one of your sub, but you considered him as a sub. I'm sorry that's all I need to conclude that GYX had intentions of letting a player who isn't on the roster participate which they had acknowledge.
  • PhiLipPiNeS™ vs Novum Vetus will be re-played.
    Sort the dates and times yourselves. If your team are not there at the time scheduled(before Saturday) your team will be DQ'd. If you cannot organise a match before this Saturday, both teams will be DQ'd.
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    clearly we won u plenty of times but u assumed that we were hacking :)
    but now when we had a fair match and u're pretty sure that it's fair u lost
    and ya it concerns me since we're supposed to be there instead of u ;)

    By all means this match between Hippo and GYX was not fair at all, since a player was not meant to even participate has done so.
  • Wivz_CF wrote: »
    PhiLipPiNeS™ vs Novum Vetus will be re-played.
    Sort the dates and times yourselves. If your team are not there at the time scheduled(before Saturday) your team will be DQ'd. If you cannot organise a match before this Saturday, both teams will be DQ'd.

    We want to play on the 29.9 (today) at 19:00 if it is possible
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    brave took the permission from tyze to play otherwise i'd never let him play .

    He never asked me about play and i would never say yes until the roster change being made on forum, all he asked me today was "can i spectnade?" and i clearly said only if the other team agree.
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    pardon me
    but who're u ? :D

    I am a member of the community, who isn't participating in this tournament. I'm here just to justify any queries or misunderstanding within this tournament.
  • Seems like GYX is telling a web of lies.

    There's no point of arguing if your just telling lies to make it go in your favour.
    Just plain pathetic.
  • Mr_Zhang wrote: »
    Seems like GYX is telling a web of lies.

    There's no point of arguing if your just telling lies to make it go in your favor.
    Just plain pathetic.

    Actually the more he tries to create more justification for his team GYX, it's drifting further more into Hippo's favor. I don't know what he is trying to achieve at the moment.

    Like I stated earlier I'm not even in this tournament and from my point of view this dispute goes to team Hippo.

    What I have said throughout the comments and remarks you have made, If I was an admin team GYX would have clearly lost this dispute. I'm not being bias, this is from a outsider's point of view.

    If you have any queries of the decision made you should contact a admin.
  • alright
    i was flamming anybody would notice this so
    i'm sorry for arguing we broke the rules we deserved the Disqualification
    but the fact that braave entered the room b4 the match has nothing to do with our teammate crash :)
    and ya i know that under different circumstances u might have won us even by a higher score there's nothing so called " we're a better team than u "
    i was just flamming so pardon me
    GL in ur next match , have fun and win FPAS :D:D
    P.S sorry for being childish :P
    ah one more thing it was all my fault that i didn't add braave as SUB since i had no time
  • Chrisve1 wrote: »
    alright
    i was flamming anybody would notice this so
    i'm sorry for arguing we broke the rules we deserved the Disqualification
    but the fact that braave entered the room b4 the match has nothing to do with our teammate crash :)
    and ya i know that under different circumstances u might have won us even by a higher score there's nothing so called " we're a better team than u "
    i was just flamming so pardon me
    GL in ur next match , have fun and win FPAS :D:D
    P.S sorry for being childish :P
    ah one more thing it was all my fault that i didn't add braave as SUB since i had no time

    Thank you for accepting this.
    I'm sure we're both good teams, and a match between us would be very close.