Another Who Would Win in GM (Multi-Year Edition)

It's late, and I'm bored... so here's the time waster GM thread that might not be seen till whenever. It's blatantly obvious as to how these things work but rather picking the winner as a 1v1 situation, pick the winner as who would be the better teammate to help win games (based on them at their peaks). Your match ups are:
FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
Banned vs pinetree
_BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
iAnarchy vs VATAV
Cynical- vs ]R[etro.
Snake? vs JudgeSim
Depado vs Ritual
*]P[iero-. vs Multiii
.*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo
themingler vs Chizz-
*]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH
Pho? vs Afterlight?
x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
Oblivion vs Waffle
ChillDawg vs NobleBeast
Scarred. vs Scout
Incursion. vs Stealth
Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
Bacon- vs -Hotshot
-pF-Andre* vs [O]zman*
Bird? vs 2
Tu vs *-.1.-*
1847 vs Marado
Charles (Pick a perm IGN please) vs Iris
Kemply vs Yash
Clayton vs Skyline
McRoSs vs SrBL
Terryaki vs Trippy?
*m4n00b* vs Smoke1
DriveBoyGoon vs *pF_Fabi*
[IDK]Muddled vs [C]hingRoarz*
Stawp vs Revan

That is all I suppose.
*edit I'll add if a matchup comes to mind and I'm bored or if a person wants to be on the list

Comments

  • since no one's replying to this and i wanna save you some embarrassment i'll help you out
    FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
    don't let recency bias fool you, i'm still the greatest to touch this game.
    Banned vs pinetree
    they're both amazing GRs with underwhelming BLs. Brad's GR was better so brad.
    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
    both godly BLs but Isaac's GR is too spray-y for my liking.
    iAnarchy vs VATAV
    from what I've seen, it's not even close
    Cynical- vs ]R[etro.
    Retro is good at bhopping and pinpointing, Cynical was alright at both but he played smart.
    Snake? vs JudgeSim
    snake's great but prime JudgeSim was almost as good as me
    Depado vs Ritual
    Depado at his peak is a 10/10 GR and 9/10 BL. Ritual at his peak is 9/10 GR 10/10 BL but he's much more consistent that Depado.
    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii
    Don't recall Piero being that great ever, Multiii killed it in motg 2016
    .*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo
    legend
    themingler vs Chizz-
    what do they have in common? they both wanted to fck lexa at one point
    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH
    not even close
    Pho? vs Afterlight?
    pho's prime was walling vs aversion
    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
    not close
    Oblivion vs Waffle
    oblivion never had a peak
    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast
    chilldawg hasn't peaked yet, still improving so he can surely overtake. but for now noble's my pick
    Scarred. vs Scout
    Incursion. vs Stealth
    prime Stealth was insane
    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
    bacardi was never good
    Bacon- vs -Hotshot
    hotshot was shovel bd spop pro
    -pF-Andre* vs [O]zman*
    Ozman never GR'd in his life
    Bird? vs 2
    Tu vs *-.1.-*
    not even gonna answer this, how can you disrespect my man Tu like this
  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
    great all round player
    Banned vs pinetree
    i think they smash each other and tie
    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
    much carry but 2 elite players
    iAnarchy vs VATAV
    haha
    Cynical- vs ]R[etro.
    i think
    Snake? vs JudgeSim
    have you seen him play? xD maybe best ever
    Depado vs Ritual
    hm
    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii
    yes
    .*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo
    just legend
    themingler vs Chizz-
    scratch
    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH
    guess idk
    Pho? vs Afterlight?
    why not?
    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
    hm
    Incursion. vs Stealth
    bad rumors of stealth
    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
    people still play gm? xd
    -pF-Andre*
    vs [O]zman*
    ozman troll xd
    Bird? vs 2
    both ok
    Tu vs *-.1.-*
    not even gonna answer this, how can you disrespect my man Tu like this
    [/Center]
  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson? - Pizza boi wins
    Banned vs pinetree - CF*Monkey Wins
    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup - Maple wins
    iAnarchy vs VATAV - Ana wins but barely
    Cynical- vs ]R[etro. - Retro rekts cynical into obvlivion because i can even kill cynical with my foot nuff said
    Snake? vs JudgeSim - Judesim
    Depado vs Ritual - Ritual more consistant
    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii - uHhhhh they tie no one wins
    .*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo - Z wins
    themingler vs Chizz - Ming wins
    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH - Lazy wins
    Pho? vs Afterlight? - Afterlight wins
    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox - mission prolly wins because i dont try but my 1v1 game op lelel so idk
    Oblivion vs Waffle - obvlivion
    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast - noble
    Scarred. vs Scout - scout
    Incursion. vs Stealth - incursion
    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz - Baka
    Bacon- vs -Hotshot - bacon
    -pF-Andre* vs [O]zman* - Ozzys op bl wins
    Bird? vs 2 - 2
    Tu vs *-.1.-* - not even gonna answer this, how can you disrespect my man Tu like this
  • Im original Pan[TH]erS member, i dont know any of these except JudgeSim. He was top 5 player back then.
  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
    Nel has consistently been a good teammate, Paul only in the last tourny
    Banned vs pinetree
    Brad likes to go fragging more than winning

    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
    My boy wanders off too much lol
    iAnarchy vs VATAV
    Both of us always played the objective
    Cynical- vs ]R[etro.
    Camps are OP vs Chop just rushing
    Snake? vs JudgeSim
    Where's Ching to ruin Sims day

    Depado vs Ritual
    Its not a 1v1 apparently lol
    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii
    Piero dies too fast sometimes

    .*_]-Z-[_*.vs Sivo
    When your hops are better than a macro
    themingler vs Chizz-

    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH

    Pho? vs Afterlight?
    The Pho that ruined Paul's dream of winning winter tourny
    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
    What are strats sleepy
    Oblivion vs Waffle

    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast
    Experience wins
    Scarred. vs Scout
    Skip

    Incursion. vs Stealth
    Don't forget Ryan in his prime was a beast
    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
    Where's Fer
    Bacon- vs -Hotshot
    Skip

    -pF-Andre* vs [O]zman*
    OG panthers vs OG FoE
    Bird? vs 2
    Would be close, but if they had the same weapons 2 wins

    Tu vs *-.1.
    Annoyingly good in general lol

    1847 vs Marado
    more of a team player

    Charles (Pick a perm IGN please) vs Iris

    Kemply vs Yash
    Even with blatant macro hops Kemply's GR was terrible
  • iAnarchy wrote: »
    snip
    ConsOrAlex wrote:
    rather picking the winner as a 1v1 situation, pick the winner as who would be the better teammate to help win games (based on them at their peaks).

    you missed the point dawg
  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
    Peaked higher, but it's close

    Banned vs pinetree
    One of 3 players I've ever had a mental block against, can't happen out of luck

    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
    Again peaks higher, recently I can vote me but he was hella scary at one point

    iAnarchy vs VATAV
    VATAV was a player that was relevant when I was just starting to get good, but thinking back that probably adds bias towards his side

    Cynical- vs ]R[etro.
    Both really good players, but Cynical was probably the strongest Aversion player before he quit

    Snake? vs JudgeSim
    Unpopular opinion for sure, but I have a lot more experience playing with Snake so I've seen him play at ridiculous levels more

    Depado vs Ritual
    Really close, but Mitch has stayed at his peak for a long time

    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii
    I feel like he has an extremely underrated BL and his GR is carry level when playing on point

    .*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo
    Obvious choice, you've probably seen me justify this in game

    themingler vs Chizz-
    Ming developed really well as a player over the last 2 years

    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH
    Very one-sided but couldn't think of anyone else to match up with Lazy

    Pho? vs Afterlight?
    I looked up to this guy a lot in my early GM days, great guy and a great player

    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
    GR vs BL matchup for the most part, really close skill wise

    Oblivion vs Waffle
    I don't think I've ever seen Waffle out frag his leader

    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast
    His GR is improving quickly and has stronger mechanical skills than me on BL. Both players are lacking game sensical stuff

    Scarred. vs Scout
    For the longest time I thought he was by far the best player in UK

    Incursion. vs Stealth
    Can't achieve god status for nothing

    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
    Bakardi is pretty much an Aversion meme to my knowledge, where Wolfie filled a carry role for GM4LYF

    Bacon- vs -Hotshot
    Only got to play with him for 2 weeks but him spanking me in a cw made me want to apply to GM4LYF

    -pF-Andre* vs [O]zman*
    Not super familiar with either of them, but Andre has good play on both sides where Oz is strictly BL sided

    Bird? vs 2
    Both good and similar in skill level, but I've never seen Bird bhop forwards o.0

    Tu vs *-.1.-*
    How can I disrespect Tu like that...

    1847 vs Marado
    Similar playstyles, but haven't seen Marado do amazing (likely due to inactivity)

    Charles (Pick a perm IGN please) vs Iris
    While admittedly Charles does have a notably better BL than Iris, his GR is virtually non-existent

    Kemply vs Yash
    The Feisty Master vs King of the Fallen, hops and ability to take a leadership role wins this one for Kemply

    Clayton vs Skyline
    Two Fallen goons, mainly a guess at this point

    McRoSs vs SrBL
    Both are talented BR players, but McRoSs has played crucial roles in developing teams

    Terryaki vs Trippy?
    Terry hasn't peaked very high in comparison but both quit GM for SnD at some point

    *m4n00b* vs Smoke1
    m4 doesn't have a formidable GR

    DriveBoyGoon vs *pF_Fabi*
    Both long time Panther reps, but I've never seen Fabi peak very high

    [IDK]Muddled vs [C]hingRoarz*
    Both were absolute monsters at their peaks, but Muddled was more relevant in a time where the avg skill lvl of a GMer was higher

    Stawp vs Revan
    Seen more from Stawp, and was Exertus s5
  • you missed the point dawg
    Lel reading directions OP, one sec
  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson?

    Pauli is support and plays passive to save the game vs Nelson? just another aggressive player


    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup

    BlackNinja is better overall

    iAnarchy vs VATAV

    Vatav 2017 shotgun sprayer

    Cynical- vs ]R[etro.

    retro useless teammate lol useless frags kills one dies in the first 20 seconds doesnt defuse cant pp **** talk game 2 good disconnects second half every cw dunno who cynical is but anyone else other than retro is a better teammate
    Can retro clutch? Absolutely (only vs fallen)


    Depado vs Ritual

    I do better playing with Depado vs when playing with Ritual, probably because of Depado's high spirits and positive attitude.


    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH

    lazysolth refuses to play with teams that he thinks he wouldn't be able to win with and when that rare occasion happens he loses and blames his team

    tldr; always getting carried


    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox




    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast

    Played a lot with both lost a lot with both noblebeast is a better player


    Incursion. vs Stealth

    Hydra 2017 > Stealth 2017


  • FrozenPizza vs Nelson?
    - Washed up vs Nelly Jelly
    Banned vs pinetree
    - Brad
    _BlAcKNiNjA_ vs MapleSyrup
    - Isaac was one scary dude to face tbh. But still going for c-coach.
    iAnarchy vs VATAV
    - Don't know who is VATAV
    Cynical- vs ]R[etro
    - Gotta give it to my blood.
    Snake? vs JudgeSim
    JudgeSim
    Depado vs Ritual
    Ritual insane spray hs is off the chart.
    *]P[iero-. vs Multiii
    Haven't seen Multii played
    .*_]-Z-[_*. vs Sivo
    A legend vs macro user sheshhhhhhhhhhhh.
    themingler vs Chizz-
    - G0dmingler
    *]M[oetaz-. vs LazYSlotH
    - Lmfao is this even a debate? Thr0wtaz throwing every single round 2 gud for him am pro hhh.
    Pho? vs Afterlight?
    - C-coach
    x.Missi0n.x vs TheSleepyFox
    - If we are talking about Mission from before he became SND then Mission but currently its the tank g0d himself foxy
    Oblivion vs Waffle
    - Oblivion called me g0d at one point
    ChillDawg vs NobleBeast
    - Chilldawg has been improving lately so gotta give it to him
    Scarred. vs Scout
    - UK G0D VS UK COPS
    Incursion. vs Stealth
    - Mr.Wayne hot junior
    Bakardi? vs Wolfie/Taz
    - Bakardi aka troll g0d
    Bacon- vs -Hotshot
    - Dont know these two
    -pF-Andre* vs [O]zman*

    Bird? vs 2
    - Dont know these two
    Tu vs *-.1.-*
    - Dont know who is 1
    1847 vs Marado
    - 1847 aka arm0r lord
    Charles (Pick a perm IGN please) vs Iris
    - Charles always dropping bomb
    Kemply vs Yash
    - Macro king vs A person who can't tell a difference between a legit player and a hacker.
  • ChingRoarz
    saints from HelloKitties
    JudgeSim

    >

    all