Distribution of Prizes
Saidin, I've stated in other threads before, but others besides RTOMan (Whom you've already removed the Golden Katana from) have the Golden Katana, and are in the exact same situation as he was.
And some of them such as [CAN]Sunrise was in the clan for an extremely short period of time, and still obtained it. I don't really mind that almost everyone in our clan received it, but those outside of the clan:
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=9974002
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=5035416
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=8542366
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=13970841
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=10362574
For example, these people ^
Shouldn't really have it as they didn't earn it and aren't even in the clan.
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below." -Taken from "The Ghosts Will Rise Again" thread created by [GM]Saidin
This states that only people that have done the 10 GM games on clan server are supposed to receive it, not those who came in during March, played 1 or 2 clan wars (Not even GM) and left.
Are you going to deal with this? Or are you going to let this slide, even though you've stated:
You've taken away RTO's Katana, are you planning to take back the others, at least those who aren't in the clan, too?
It would make a lot more sense, honestly.
I'm not being a ****, I just find it unpleasant that people can get the main prize of this tournament, when they've joined for less than a week and left the clan.
And some of them such as [CAN]Sunrise was in the clan for an extremely short period of time, and still obtained it. I don't really mind that almost everyone in our clan received it, but those outside of the clan:
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=9974002
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=5035416
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=8542366
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=13970841
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=10362574
For example, these people ^
Shouldn't really have it as they didn't earn it and aren't even in the clan.
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below." -Taken from "The Ghosts Will Rise Again" thread created by [GM]Saidin
This states that only people that have done the 10 GM games on clan server are supposed to receive it, not those who came in during March, played 1 or 2 clan wars (Not even GM) and left.
Are you going to deal with this? Or are you going to let this slide, even though you've stated:
[GM]Saidin wrote: »If you are referring specifically to RTO, he fell into the correct pool mathematically and received a katana, but it was removed after a double-check was performed.
You've taken away RTO's Katana, are you planning to take back the others, at least those who aren't in the clan, too?
It would make a lot more sense, honestly.
I'm not being a ****, I just find it unpleasant that people can get the main prize of this tournament, when they've joined for less than a week and left the clan.
Comments
-
Additionally, regarding your post earlier:[GM]Saidin wrote: »We realized that although we want to give prizes to people that participated, we had to go by our rules set out from the original. Which was 10 Clan matches on the clan server. It was never stipulated in the original rules that it had to be ghost mode.
Wasn't this:
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below." -Taken from "The Ghosts Will Rise Again" thread created by [GM]Saidin
Original Thread: http://forum.z8games.com/showthread.php?t=199067
Part of the "original rules"?
It does say 10 Ghost Mode games on the Clan Server is required, doesn't it? -
I've also heard that Natt got it.
I can understand that, but I just don't understand. Was the number of people in our clan that would have gotten the Katana "legitimately" too few for you, or something?
I don't get how a mistake like this can occur, lol.
Well, the fact that RTO's Katana was taken back should mean that the others that I've listed should be dealt with as well.
Gods and I both think that the rules have been randomly changing too much, lol.
Hope you see and reply to my 1st&2nd posts. -
It does just say 10 games of GM Clan match. It doesn't seem to specify the clan, so following those rules they should get it. however i agree with you, it's not just if said people get the top prize for not helping the clan win. Perhaps a 'been with the clan for X months' rule would have been good, but hindsight is a wonderful thing.
-
It does just say 10 games of GM Clan match. It doesn't seem to specify the clan, so following those rules they should get it. however i agree with you, it's not just if said people get the top prize for not helping the clan win. Perhaps a 'been with the clan for X months' rule would have been good, but hindsight is a wonderful thing.
The fact that RTO's Katana was taken back should be enough of a reason to take the Katanas away from the players that I've mentioned above, and perhaps more that I failed to notice. Since they're in identical situations compared to RTO. -
It says: "All Members of the winning clan who play more than a total of 10 games on the Clan Server during the tournament period will receive an Exclusive Permanent Gold Katana" Learn to read..Additionally, regarding your post earlier:
Wasn't this:
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below." -Taken from "The Ghosts Will Rise Again" thread created by [GM]Saidin
Original Thread: http://forum.z8games.com/showthread.php?t=199067
Part of the "original rules"?
It does say 10 Ghost Mode games on the Clan Server is required, doesn't it? -
Shadow_Alien wrote: »It says: "All Members of the winning clan who play more than a total of 10 games on the Clan Server during the tournament period will receive an Exclusive Permanent Gold Katana" Learn to read..
It initially said:
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below."
Before they mentioned it again in the prizes section, learn to think.
I also asked several Moderators about this particular thing (whether it was 10 GM CWs or not), and they all told me that you needed to do GM clan wars. -
Saidin, I've stated in other threads before, but others besides RTOMan (Whom you've already removed the Golden Katana from) have the Golden Katana, and are in the exact same situation as he was.
And some of them such as [CAN]Sunrise was in the clan for an extremely short period of time, and still obtained it. I don't really mind that almost everyone in our clan received it, but those outside of the clan:
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=9974002
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=5035416
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=8542366
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=13970841
http://clan.z8games.com/charstat_cf.aspx?usn=10362574
For example, these people ^
Shouldn't really have it as they didn't earn it and aren't even in the clan.
"Players must play a minimum of 10 GM games on the clan server in the month of March to qualify themselves to win the main prizes listed below." -Taken from "The Ghosts Will Rise Again" thread created by [GM]Saidin
This states that only people that have done the 10 GM games on clan server are supposed to receive it, not those who came in during March, played 1 or 2 clan wars (Not even GM) and left.
Are you going to deal with this? Or are you going to let this slide, even though you've stated:
You've taken away RTO's Katana, are you planning to take back the others, at least those who aren't in the clan, too?
It would make a lot more sense, honestly.
I'm not being a ****, I just find it unpleasant that people can get the main prize of this tournament, when they've joined for less than a week and left the clan.
We can give prizes to whomever we want.
The casters got the Gold Katana as well. This prize is not exclusive to ONLY this tournaments winners.
Based on our rules set out here:
http://forum.z8games.com/showthread.php?t=199067
The players who played 10 or more Clan Games for the clan OldLegends in March received prizes.
We'll have to look at the join/leave days within the clan to see about adjusting this. However, considering you were so careful about the rules, I am surprised you wouldn't have noted that the original announcement said nothing about whether or not a player in the clan could receive the prize after they left the clan later.All Members of the winning clan who play more than a total of 10 games on the Clan Server during the tournament period will receive an Exclusive Permanent Gold Katana
And that being said, considering your top groups had full control over the OldLegends roster during the month of March, my suggestion would be to have looked more at who you were letting in and out of the clan.
Lastly, we seem to be dealing with an elitist attitude from some of the prize winners, this is something we've seen in the past. However please note that we have the ability to run events and give out prizes to whomever we choose. Based on the reactions here, we'll likely find ways to give away this item to even more people.
![MissA]Suzy](https://z8games.akamaized.net/cfna/forum/customavatars/24/navatar_4061724.gif){kind=avatar}
![]K[illa](https://z8games.akamaized.net/cfna/forum/customavatars/79/navatar_6049979.gif){kind=avatar}
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- Z8Games
- Off-Topic - Go To Game OT Forums
- 1 Z8 Forum Discussion & Suggestions
- 16 Z8Games Announcements
- Rules & Conduct
- 5.2K CrossFire
- 974 CrossFire Announcements
- 968 Previous Announcements
- 2 Previous Patch Notes
- 1.4K Community
- 121 Modes
- 606 Suggestions
- 85 Clan Discussion and Recruitment
- 274 CF Competitive Forum
- 19 CFCL
- 26 Looking for a Team?
- 715 CrossFire Support
- 54 Suggestion
- 119 Bugs
- 29 CrossFire Guides
- 168 Technical Issues
- 47 CrossFire Off Topic