CFGC Explains 5 star scoring system + new review
Ok so there has been a few complaints on how we score different guns in our reviews. I made this thread to basically sort a few things out, also to promote a new Reviews made by SixCBeast, Soda, and street:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LBD6s1FLCHI&feature=channel (M16 Review)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T695YsjXXm0 (Gatling Review)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gb4uuFAey9w&feature=channel (Ak-47 Review)
The 5 Star Scoring System goes like this:
There are 5 different Categories each with their own individual standards, but also they are intertwined. (Meaning one affects how the other is scored based on compatibility)
1. Power (How much damage the gun does. RoF may also affect the power.) Ex: The uzi and the m9 should have received a 0/5, but because both of their Rate of Fires were more than decent they got 1/5.
2. Maneuverability (How fast you can run with a gun/ How heavy the gun is...Also how small the gun is can affect MVB.) Ex: The p90 was a little bit on the heavy side (my opinion) for an SMG, but because it's small and compact it received a better score.
3. Rate of Fire (How fast the gun shoots, the spray pattern and accuracy may also affect the outcome of this category.)
4. Accuracy (How accurate a certain gun is...RoF, and spray pattern may also effect how this is scored.)
5. Ammo/Reload speed (How much ammunition a certain gun has, and how fast it can be reloaded. This was going to be split up into different categories, but the 5,5,5 thing rolled off the tounge.)
If you do not understand how we here at TheCFGC rate the various weapons of Crossfire I am deeply sorry. We will however not change the way we Rate weapons...If you think that all guns are going/are rated the same you are sorely mistaken...keep watching as the gun we review next will have higher scores..because of the weapons.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LBD6s1FLCHI&feature=channel (M16 Review)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T695YsjXXm0 (Gatling Review)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gb4uuFAey9w&feature=channel (Ak-47 Review)
The 5 Star Scoring System goes like this:
There are 5 different Categories each with their own individual standards, but also they are intertwined. (Meaning one affects how the other is scored based on compatibility)
1. Power (How much damage the gun does. RoF may also affect the power.) Ex: The uzi and the m9 should have received a 0/5, but because both of their Rate of Fires were more than decent they got 1/5.
2. Maneuverability (How fast you can run with a gun/ How heavy the gun is...Also how small the gun is can affect MVB.) Ex: The p90 was a little bit on the heavy side (my opinion) for an SMG, but because it's small and compact it received a better score.
3. Rate of Fire (How fast the gun shoots, the spray pattern and accuracy may also affect the outcome of this category.)
4. Accuracy (How accurate a certain gun is...RoF, and spray pattern may also effect how this is scored.)
5. Ammo/Reload speed (How much ammunition a certain gun has, and how fast it can be reloaded. This was going to be split up into different categories, but the 5,5,5 thing rolled off the tounge.)
If you do not understand how we here at TheCFGC rate the various weapons of Crossfire I am deeply sorry. We will however not change the way we Rate weapons...If you think that all guns are going/are rated the same you are sorely mistaken...keep watching as the gun we review next will have higher scores..because of the weapons.
Comments
-
-
Since when did Crossfire-USA Gatling gun appread?? I havent been on in like 2 months
Other then that, man unexplainable progress you guys are making and cant wait when i get my After Effects back
came out last patch
were you been. Can't wait to see some of you sick effects. SixCBeast talks alot about you ^_- -
Since when did Crossfire-USA Gatling gun appread?? I havent been on in like 2 months
Other then that, man unexplainable progress you guys are making and cant wait when i get my After Effects back
The Gatling Gun has come out in MM only in crates...I'ts a hard weapon to review...Because the ammount of time it takes to get the weapon...Near impossible to get review footage in an actual match.
And thanks for your support, can't wait for you to join the team. -
For MVB (2)...
Since it does not include run 'n' gun ability, I'm surprised why the Scar Light was rated so low here. It's very light for a rifle. Why is the physical size considered? The only issue here would be if you camp a wall and your gun tip sticks out, but that's hardly manoeuvrability...
They were nice, unfortunately there are some quality inconsistencies, but the content was there. I think it would be great if you guys collaborated more and made a standard style+intro so it could be seen as a joint project (perhaps ask TaMz for an intro?). -
AK-47 3points for Accurate? lol fortunately the guy witch make the review said that he is a sprayer so i can understand why he give the gun a 3 xD
p.s i dont know how many you are but only 1 of you guys make good Reviews the others have shi.t quality and i cant here anything what they say :S
RSCHOLOKOV -
For MVB (2)...
Since it does not include run 'n' gun ability, I'm surprised why the Scar Light was rated so low here. It's very light for a rifle. Why is the physical size considered? The only issue here would be if you camp a wall and your gun tip sticks out, but that's hardly manoeuvrability...
They were nice, unfortunately there are some quality inconsistencies, but the content was there. I think it would be great if you guys collaborated more and made a standard style+intro so it could be seen as a joint project (perhaps ask TaMz for an intro?).
Yea, We have been looking for a Effects man (One who can make intros, wallpapers, etc) Since our guy won't be able to start working on it until September. And I already tried to contact Tamz a while back...but I guess he doesn't answer pm's on the forums from strangers... -
RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »AK-47 3points for Accurate? lol fortunately the guy witch make the review said that he is a sprayer so i can understand why he give the gun a 3 xD
p.s i dont know how many you are but only 1 of you guys make good Reviews the others have shi.t quality and i cant here anything what they say :S
RSCHOLOKOV
In my opinion, accuracy also means recoil which is why it got down a bit. I see your from Ukraine so I'm sorry if I hurt your Russian pride
Ak would have gotten a 3 even if I didn't spray, M4 dominates at long range due to the fact that the M4s accurate bursts beat the AKs tapping.
and we have different computers so our quality won't always be the same. -
RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »AK-47 3points for Accurate? lol fortunately the guy witch make the review said that he is a sprayer so i can understand why he give the gun a 3 xD
p.s i dont know how many you are but only 1 of you guys make good Reviews the others have shi.t quality and i cant here anything what they say :S
RSCHOLOKOV
Not being rude but if you have a problem with the quality buy us some new graphic cards or better yet new computers -.- -
In my opinion, accuracy also means recoil which is why it got down a bit. I see your from Ukraine so I'm sorry if I hurt your Russian pride
Ak would have gotten a 3 even if I didn't spray, M4 dominates at long range due to the fact that the M4s accurate bursts beat the AKs tapping.
and we have different computers so our quality won't always be the same.
Im from Ukraine so dont start with any thing like this. Russian .... blalba im not Russian im Ukraine ,and make no sense they say 5 scoring system #1Power.2Accurate,3Recoil,4ROF,5Reload so its a fail to say Recoil+Accurate =1 point
btw if you want lets go on 1vs1 AK vs M4 (only Long Long Range Shooting I bet i would win against you AK is More Accurate i just need 1 Bullet on the Head not Brusting ,and you can look on INGAME STATS AK+Accurate M4- Lower accurate as AK
there is nothing with Russian pride or anything its just a fact
and to you well what can i say just stfu pls nothing elseNot being rude but if you have a problem with the quality buy us some new graphic cards or better yet new computers -.-
compare the videos from the differen gun Reviews witch this guys did and you will se only1 of them have a good Recording Programm so stfu with your tipps like get a New PC my PC is Fine ..... p.s i hope i dont hurt you last 3 days im just not realy friendly i have problems in reallife :S but i hope you take it not personly or something like that
RSCHOLOKOV -
RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »make no sense they say 5 scoring system #1Power.2Accurate,3Recoil,4ROF,5Reload so its a fail to say Recoil+Accurate =1 point
btw if you want lets go on 1vs1 AK vs M4 (only Long Long Range Shooting I bet i would win against you AK is More Accurate i just need 1 Bullet on the Head not Brusting ,and you can look on INGAME STATS AK+Accurate M4- Lower accurate as AK
First off it's the 5 star scoring system, with 5 categories
1. Power
2. MVB
3. RoF
4. Accuracy
5. Ammo/Reload
Second...1v1 to prove what gun is more accurate won't work...only for that fact that the players skill level plays a roll in their overall accuracy. -
Once again, not being rude, but can you not read? I never said for you to get a new computer, if your pc is fine then congrats, I said if you have a problem with the quality then buy US new graphic cards or buy US new computers. I have a terrible computer, while recording I get about 18 fps. So using any other recording program drops my fps below 10. And btw the ranking system is 1.Power, 2. Manuverability, 3. Rate of Fire, 4. Accuracy, and 5. reload rate/ammo
common sense says recoil would affect the guns accuracy, if you want it just based on how accurate a one shot is then every gun would get a 5/5 cause every guns first bullet is dead on unless its broken -.-
and if you still don't really get what accuracy is based on its pretty much how tight the bullets are together so once again common sense says the recoil affects the accuracy -
RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »Im from Ukraine so dont start with any thing like this. Russian .... blalba im not Russian im Ukraine ,and make no sense they say 5 scoring system #1Power.2Accurate,3Recoil,4ROF,5Reload so its a fail to say Recoil+Accurate =1 point
btw if you want lets go on 1vs1 AK vs M4 (only Long Long Range Shooting I bet i would win against you AK is More Accurate i just need 1 Bullet on the Head not Brusting ,and you can look on INGAME STATS AK+Accurate M4- Lower accurate as AK
there is nothing with Russian pride or anything its just a fact
and to you well what can i say just stfu pls nothing else
compare the videos from the differen gun Reviews witch this guys did and you will se only1 of them have a good Recording Programm so stfu with your tipps like get a New PC my PC is Fine ..... p.s i hope i dont hurt you last 3 days im just not realy friendly i have problems in reallife :S but i hope you take it not personly or something like that
RSCHOLOKOV
Ukraine has strong ties with Russia and the fact that your speaking russian expects me to believe you have some pride
Even Malte says he has a hard time playing against elite m4 users at long range
oh and BTW, I don't have an M4, sold it for an XM8 -
oh yeah sry i dont read it carfeully but yeah like i said ,i fell very sad the last days so sry if i hurt somebody i say sry if i did itOnce again, not being rude, but can you not read? I never said for you to get a new computer, if your pc is fine then congrats, I said if you have a problem with the quality then buy US new graphic cards or buy US new computers. I have a terrible computer, while recording I get about 18 fps. So using any other recording program drops my fps below 10. And btw the ranking system is 1.Power, 2. Manuverability, 3. Rate of Fire, 4. Accuracy, and 5. reload rate/ammo
common sense says recoil would affect the guns accuracy, if you want it just based on how accurate a one shot is then every gun would get a 5/5 cause every guns first bullet is dead on unless its broken -.-
and if you still don't really get what accuracy is based on its pretty much how tight the bullets are together so once again common sense says the recoil affects the accuracy
btw not every gun does 1hit head shoot and not every gun is accurate in 1 shoot i noticed it by G36 shoot the guns at a point in the wall 1 shoot let it cool down shoot again let it cool down after some shoots the bullet move a lil bit away from the hole in the wall
and yeah SMG dont do 1 shoot headshoot pistols dont do it at long range so yeah recoil is a only a part witch make a gun inaccurate at hit targets nothing else ,if you want a better Record try to put all your programms witch you dont need off+delete your cookies every time if you want to play + try Clean Up 30days free (after need Key should help you)Ukraine has strong ties with Russia and the fact that your speaking russian expects me to believe you have some pride
Even Malte says he has a hard time playing against elite m4 users at long range
oh and BTW, I don't have an M4, sold it for an XM8
yeah its true aboute the Strong ties but they are 2 different Countrys its a bad compair to say only because we speak russian( we don´t ,we can but we have our Ukrainisch ,Ukraine ppl just speak more russian because in the CCCP it was like the World language for the 15 states from the CCCP)
its a bad compair its like i compair ;USA+UK+Australia ? you all speak English you are all 1 its not true you have all your own culture the 1 Eats to mutch Fast Food and think they are the World Police, The other Like Black Tea , and the others Hunt kangaroo (XD) so yeah Strong ties but not same.
RSCHOLOKOV -
Good job actually, one thing that I think is wrong is the gattling's accuracy. I don't know if the ROF makes up for this, but I can actually land bullets IN the mutants while continuously spraying. Recoil is like RPK, maybe even easier to actually aim. Or at least, that's what it looks like to me (my results with MGs ain't that good tho).
-
-
Good job actually, one thing that I think is wrong is the gattling's accuracy. I don't know if the ROF makes up for this, but I can actually land bullets IN the mutants while continuously spraying. Recoil is like RPK, maybe even easier to actually aim. Or at least, that's what it looks like to me (my results with MGs ain't that good tho).
Good, and honest. Things look bright for you Emotive.platapierule wrote: »Yay, a non-trash review!
Thanks man, but we are still trying to improve on certain areas of our reviews.Kyle
. Ily, get into my belly?
Red...I didn't know you trolled the forums. -
Well, it's just my opinion ^^'' ... Now I'm far from being an MG user on a regular basis, so I might be wrong, but yeah, anyways ^^''SexyBeasting wrote: »Good, and honest. Things look bright for you Emotive.
Thanks man, but we are still trying to improve on certain areas of our reviews.
Red...I didn't know you trolled the forums. -
Accuracy is a null point if you think about 1st shot from stationary position to stationary target.RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »AK-47 3points for Accurate? lol fortunately the guy witch make the review said that he is a sprayer so i can understand why he give the gun a 3 xD
You can see SixC points out RoF & spray pattern contribute - that is good, accuracy is not a good category on its own. Spray pattern would be affected by the high recoil, and RoF is not bad, but not amazing.SexyBeasting wrote: »4. Accuracy (How accurate a certain gun is...RoF, and spray pattern may also effect how this is scored.)
And here's an example of another practical accuracy - how well-placed or controllable are the follow-up shots to the first one.In my opinion, accuracy also means recoil which is why it got down a bit.
May I just enquire at what range this is, and how long you waited for it to cool down? If it's fully cooled down, it shouldn't be that inaccurate - maybe I've got some testing to do. In my experience, rifles can miss by perhaps a pixel at long range (hmm, say BW spawn-to-spawn).RSCHOLOKOV wrote: »not every gun is accurate in 1 shoot i noticed it by G36 shoot the guns at a point in the wall 1 shoot let it cool down shoot again let it cool down after some shoots the bullet move a lil bit away from the hole in the wall
Sorry for using you as an example RSCHOLOKOV, I simply wanted to clear up the "accuracy" issue I see around. -
Accuracy is a null point if you think about 1st shot from stationary position to stationary target.
You can see SixC points out RoF & spray pattern contribute - that is good, accuracy is not a good category on its own. Spray pattern would be affected by the high recoil, and RoF is not bad, but not amazing.
And here's an example of another practical accuracy - how well-placed or controllable are the follow-up shots to the first one.
May I just enquire at what range this is, and how long you waited for it to cool down? If it's fully cooled down, it shouldn't be that inaccurate - maybe I've got some testing to do. In my experience, rifles can miss by perhaps a pixel at long range (hmm, say BW spawn-to-spawn).
Sorry for using you as an example RSCHOLOKOV, I simply wanted to clear up the "accuracy" issue I see around.
no problem this time you did nothing wrong you dont post anything about me or dont post trash so you dont need to say sry its ok
btw its true with the G36 i let it cool down but after some shoots the bullet jumped out of the hole and hit 2mm more left
RSCHOLOKOV
Categories
- All Categories
- Z8Games
- Off-Topic - Go To Game OT Forums
- 1 Z8 Forum Discussion & Suggestions
- 16 Z8Games Announcements
- Rules & Conduct
- 5.2K CrossFire
- 951 CrossFire Announcements
- 942 Previous Announcements
- 2 Previous Patch Notes
- 1.4K Community
- 122 Modes
- 600 Suggestions
- 85 Clan Discussion and Recruitment
- 274 CF Competitive Forum
- 19 CFCL
- 26 Looking for a Team?
- 702 CrossFire Support
- 52 Suggestion
- 116 Bugs
- 28 CrossFire Guides
- 166 Technical Issues
- 47 CrossFire Off Topic